Byrne Dairy Recalls Mighty Fine Chocolate Ice Cream in Half Gallons Dated 10/4/2024 Due to Undeclared Peanuts

Raleigh, N.C., Jan. 14, 2026 — Byrne Dairy, Inc. has recalled its Byrne Dairy Mighty Fine Chocolate Ice Cream half‑gallon cartons because the product may contain undeclared peanuts, posing a serious or life‑threatening risk to people with peanut allergies; consumers who purchased the affected product are urged not to eat it and should stop using it immediately. The company reports no illnesses to date and initiated the voluntary recall after a consumer complaint and a manufacturing error resulted in peanut butter being distributed in cartons not labeled to disclose peanuts.

The recall covers Byrne Dairy Mighty Fine Chocolate Ice Cream in 1/2‑gallon (half‑gallon) cardboard cartons bearing the printed “Last Date of Sale: 10/4/2024”; lot code(s) correspond to the cartons with that sale date. The product has been sold since Oct. 4, 2024, online and at select U.S. retailers, primarily distributed in retail stores throughout Upstate New York; the recall involves no more than 250 half‑gallon units.

Consumers should dispose of the product or return it to the place of purchase for a full refund, or contact Byrne Dairy for instructions on return or replacement and to request a refund; for questions or claims, call Ashley Casey at (315) 627‑1319 between 9:00 a.m. and 5:00 p.m. EST or email [email protected]. If you have a severe allergy and have consumed the product, seek medical attention immediately. For additional details not listed here, consumers should check Byrne Dairy’s website or contact the company directly.