Anthony's Pizza Menu > 1 Location in West Islip 4.5 based on 124 votes Name Address Phone Address and Phone Anthony's Pizza - West Islip - New York 791 Udall Rd (631) 321-4100 Anthony's Pizza Hours in Nearby Cities Albany Bohemia Bronx Brooklyn Carle Place Centereach Commack Great Neck Huntington Station Johnstown Maspeth Merrick People Also Viewed Subway 3.5 1 McDonald's 3.2 1 Donatos 3.2 1 Papa John's Pizza 2.1 1 Chuck E Cheese's 4.5 1 7 Eleven 4.1 2 Quiznos 3.2 1 Harvey's 4.1 1 Betty's 4.5 1 Anthony's Pizza 4.5 1 You May Also Like La Hacienda Menu 4.6 Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Menu 4.2 La Fiesta Menu 4.5 China Wok Menu 3.8 Acapulco Menu 4.8 Sunset Grill Menu 4.6 Bella Pizza Menu 4.7 Dion's Pizza Menu 4.4 Cattle Baron Menu 4.4 Pizza Roma Menu 4.6
