Casey's Menu > 2 Locations in Sheridan 4.0 based on 333 votes Name Address Phone Address and Phone Casey's - Sheridan - Indiana 501 S Main St (317) 758-0951 Casey's - Sheridan - Indiana 21737 Mulebarn Rd (317) 694-7521 Casey's Hours in Nearby Cities Alexandria Arcadia Bainbridge Battle Ground Brownsburg Carmel Crawfordsville Danville Elwood Greenfield Indianapolis Kokomo People Also Viewed Dairy Queen 3.3 1 Casey's 4.0 2 Harvey's 4.1 1 You May Also Like Paparoni's Pizza Menu 4.9 Snappy Tomato Pizza Menu 4.7 El Senor Frogs Menu 4.6 Hometown Pizza Menu 4.6 Lupe Tortilla Menu 4.6 Lamberts Cafe Menu 4.6 Ming Hing Restaurant Menu 4.5 China #1 Menu 4.2 Mazzio's Pizza Menu 4.5 Hunan House Menu 4.4
