Casey's Menu > 2 Locations in Mahopac 4.0 based on 329 votes Name Address Phone Address and Phone Casey's - Mahopac - New York 4 Park Hill Ter (845) 621-5095 Casey's - Mahopac - New York 31 Red Mills Rd (845) 628-1379 Casey's Hours in Nearby Cities Albertson Brewster Bronx Cold Spring Cortlandt Manor Croton-on-Hudson Flushing Haverstraw Huntington Kingston Manhasset New City People Also Viewed McDonald's 3.2 1 Dunkin' Donuts 3.5 1 Planet Wings 5.0 1 Rao's 4.4 1 Casey's 4.0 2 China Garden 4.2 1 China Garden Restaurant 4.0 1 Houlihan's 4.3 1 Tony's Pizzeria 4.8 1 Chan's Garden 4.8 1 You May Also Like Paparoni's Pizza Menu 4.9 Snappy Tomato Pizza Menu 4.7 El Senor Frogs Menu 4.6 Hometown Pizza Menu 4.6 Lupe Tortilla Menu 4.6 Lamberts Cafe Menu 4.6 Ming Hing Restaurant Menu 4.5 China #1 Menu 4.2 Mazzio's Pizza Menu 4.5 Hunan House Menu 4.4