Casey's Menu > 1 Location in Shelter Island 4.0 based on 329 votes Name Address Phone Address and Phone Casey's - Shelter Island - New York 2 Grand Ave (631) 749-1235 Casey's Hours in Nearby Cities Albertson Babylon Brewster Brookhaven Commack East Hampton East Meadow Floral Park Huntington Manhasset Massapequa Merrick People Also Viewed Casey's 4.0 1 Town Hall 4.9 1 Bella Pizza 4.7 1 You May Also Like Paparoni's Pizza Menu 4.9 Snappy Tomato Pizza Menu 4.7 El Senor Frogs Menu 4.6 Hometown Pizza Menu 4.6 Lupe Tortilla Menu 4.6 Lamberts Cafe Menu 4.6 Ming Hing Restaurant Menu 4.5 China #1 Menu 4.2 Mazzio's Pizza Menu 4.5 Hunan House Menu 4.4
