Pizza Plus Menu > 1 Location in New Carlisle 4.3 based on 153 votes Name Address Phone Address and Phone Pizza Plus - New Carlisle - Ohio 101 Galewood Dr (937) 845-1005 Pizza Plus Hours in Nearby Cities Akron Athens Byesville Caldwell Cambridge Chardon Columbus Coshocton Gallipolis Lancaster Mansfield Mentor People Also Viewed Domino's Pizza 2.9 1 Subway 3.5 2 McDonald's 3.2 1 Papa John's Pizza 2.1 1 China Wok 3.8 1 Lee's Famous Recipe Chicken 3.6 1 Casey's 4.0 1 Pizza Plus 4.3 1 Pizza King 4.3 1 Best China 4.5 1 You May Also Like Sakura Menu 4.4 Pronto Pizza Menu 4.4 Pappa Pey Pey Pizza Menu 4.7 Sal's Pizza Menu 4.4 Sam's Pizza Menu 4.8 Taco City Menu 4.8 Hoss's Steak & Sea House Menu 4.6 Pizza King Menu 4.3 Garden Cafe Menu 4.6 Village Inn Menu 4.4
