Sugar Shack Menu > 1 Location in Islandia 4.4 based on 129 votes Name Address Phone Address and Phone Sugar Shack - Islandia - New York 83 Shafter St (631) 582-5699 Sugar Shack Hours in Nearby Cities Binghamton Breezy Point Elmira Heights Freedom Ithaca Lake Placid Lockport Middletown Penn Yan Portland Pulaski Sayville People Also Viewed Subway 3.5 1 McDonald's 3.2 1 7 Eleven 4.1 3 Dave & Buster's 4.4 1 Grand Buffet 4.0 1 TGI Friday's 4.4 1 Sugar Shack 4.4 1 Yogurt City 4.7 1 T. G. I. Friday's 4.9 1 Harvey's 4.1 1 You May Also Like Tokyo Steakhouse Menu 4.5 Galaxy Diner Menu 4.4 Roy Rogers Menu 4.5 J & J Fish & Chicken Menu 4.6 Oh Shucks Menu 4.6 La Cantina Menu 4.5 Long Doggers Menu 4.8 Osaka Japanese Steakhouse Menu 4.5 Shark's Fish & Chicken Menu 4.0 J. Christopher's Menu 4.8
